Skip to main content

The worst trope in fantasy

    Oh boy, a catchy title that makes a massive generalization. 

    What I'm about to talk about probably isn't the worst trope in fantasy. But it's definitely one of the weirdest, especially in contemporary literature.

    For some reason, fantasy authors just LOVE monarchies.

    I don't get it. Pretty much every fantasy book that I've read (that involves succession or just a king, which is most of them) implicitly supports monarchies. Sure, they have the evil king Mazgarazoth, iron-fisted tyrant of the grim lands of Scary Sadness. But, opposing the vile blackguard is the good king John, who rules his lands with a soft hand and loves his subjects. He also somehow maintains the economy even though he takes pity and lets peasants not pay taxes, and also, quite luckily, is descended from a long line of similarly paragon rulers, and his son is virtuous and angelic, and will grow into a good king. 

    (If you couldn't tell, that was sarcastic)

    (The "good king" is also often replaced with a rightful heir good king, who has to violently and illegally usurp the evil king to institute a similarly monarchical regime)

    This exact sequence of event happens all the time. The Ranger's Apprentice series has King Duncan, the Lord of the Rings chronicle has Aragorn, even Egyptian Mythology has the rightful heir good king Horus beating back the evil king Set. Horus is kind of justified, though, seeing as he's an explicitly good god and therefore probably pretty moral. 

    Now, in case you didn't know, the reason this trope is bad is because monarchies are generally pretty bad. Sure, you'll have various good kings, but the fact that the ruler is determined by the very dicey process of genetic inheritance means that the king won't always be good. And if the king isn't good, or goes senile and appoints their favorite table to the position of chief baronial advisor, what are you going to do about it? Kill him? Whoops, looks like your peasant mob got killed by the king's elite royal corps (in Rome, the elite royal corps killed the emperor a whole lot, but we won't talk about that). Oh wait, some bloke from across the channel is offering his help! With his army, we can topple the aging tyrant! Wait a minute, we just instated a new tyrant, but French. 

    So yeah, monarchies are pretty bad; even if not for the aforementioned reasons, there's a reason why no more true monarchies exist. They just function worse than republics. You could say that the characters are just acting like they would in their time period. And you would be correct. But there's no reason for authors to pose those actions as explicitly positive. 

    That's it, please argue in the comments because it would be funny.

-Marco


Comments

  1. WilliamApril 15, 2021 at 1:43 PM

    Excellent generalization of a massive genre! I didn't realize how much I come across this issue until now, coming from a person who doesn't read very much fantasy. I look forward to your next controversial take.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yan LApril 18, 2021 at 7:37 PM

    I completely agree with what you have said, usually in real life, specifically for monarchies, the first ruler is often the best ruler. This is why whenever a fantasy novel ends all I can think about is what would happen if the future generations of the ruler's are evil.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Miranda BurgosApril 21, 2021 at 8:16 PM

    I agree, monarchy is a very common fantasy trope. To be honest, I'm not sure what the obsession with it is. Most people have been engrossed in it since we were just children with fairytales of princes and princesses, but what is it really that people find so fascinating about this? No idea, though I will say that when I was little a lot of the books I wrote involved royalty and I still find it kind of interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Evan W.April 22, 2021 at 9:19 AM

    Yep. I think this is true because so much of fantasy is based off of the medieval aesthetic. With that medieval theme comes monarchies, knights, and folklore. Lots of fantasy takes stuff from Tolkien and he explored monarchy in his books.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Book Recommendation: The Fault in Our Stars

 The Fault in Our Stars, by John Green, is a well written and captivating book. It follows the story of a teenage girl named Hazel. Years ago she was diagnosed with lung cancer, and she is already past her life expectancy. She has been spending her days sitting at home and watching bad tv, having been taken out of school several years ago. She attends a cancer support group from time to time, where she meets a boy named Augustus Waters. Pretty quickly they fall in love, and experience the ups and downs of life together. This book is great. It's funny, and I think it does a surprisingly good job at portraying the mind of a teenager. It's a good romance novel, and it does a great job at making you feel sympathy for cancer patients, but that isn't all its about, either. It's also a tragedy. It teaches a lesson that a lot happens in life that isn't fair. Suffering is inevitable, a part of life, a side effect. Not everything goes to plan, either, so when you find somethi...
6 comments
Read more

The Future of Humanity

I have always loved the dystopian genre. I think what the author writes reflects how they view our world and what they think will come of it. Books like these have always captivated me as they transport my imagination into a potential version of the world I see today. This month I read Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials and it led me to question how I believe the world will change in the future. Personally, I believe that unless the majority/ the entire human race changes our way of living we are going to destroy our earth. With that being said I also believe that our earth is on an undefined time limit, meaning that sooner or later our earth will end/ it won't exist anymore whether that is due to climate change and pollution or some other unidentified threat. In the maze runner there was a disease outbreak which eventually led to an apocalypse like world where there was a dictatorship and a rebellion. This view of how our world could unfold made me think about how human actions speci...
4 comments
Read more

Aosop Fables Life Lessons

 This month I read Aesop's fables which is essentially a book filled with short stories/ fables with a moral of the story written at the end of the fable. Aesop fables is an unconventional reading choice but I still feel like it's really fun if you wanted to just add a little bit of diversity in your reading selection.  One of my all time favorite fables was/is the ants and the grasshopper:  A Grasshopper that had merrily sung all summer was almost perishing with hunger in the winter. So she went to some Ants that lived near, and asked them to lend her a little food they had put by. "You shall certainly be paid before this time of year comes again," said she. "What did you do all the summer?" asked they. "Why, all day long and all night long I sang, if you please," answered the grasshopper. "Oh you sang, did you?" said the Ants. "Now, then you can dance."  Provide today for the future. I really enjoyed this fable because I int...
2 comments
Read more